Day 14 - Impact of Computing Project - Development
Day 14: Impact of Computing Project - Development
Learning Objectives
- All unit objectives
Essential Questions
- How can we analyze the impacts of computing innovations comprehensively?
- How do we research and evaluate computing innovations from multiple perspectives?
- How can we effectively communicate about the impacts of computing?
Materials Needed
- Final project requirements handout
- Computing innovation research guides
- Impact analysis templates
- Presentation planning worksheets
- Research resources (devices with internet access)
- Exit ticket templates
Vocabulary
- Computing innovation
- Impact analysis
- Beneficial effects
- Harmful effects
- Stakeholder analysis
- Research methodology
- Evidence-based claims
- Presentation design
- Citation
- Balanced analysis
Procedure (50 minutes)
Opening (10 minutes)
-
Introduction to Final Project Requirements (7 minutes)
- Explain the purpose of the final project:
- To demonstrate understanding of computing innovations and their impacts
- To apply analytical frameworks from the unit
- To practice research and presentation skills
- Present project requirements:
- Select a specific computing innovation to analyze
- Research the innovation's development and purpose
- Analyze impacts from multiple perspectives
- Consider beneficial and harmful effects
- Examine legal, ethical, and social dimensions
- Create a presentation to share findings
- Discuss evaluation criteria:
- Depth of research and analysis
- Consideration of multiple perspectives
- Balance between benefits and harms
- Quality of evidence and reasoning
- Clarity of presentation
- Share timeline and expectations
- Explain the purpose of the final project:
-
Brainstorming Project Ideas (3 minutes)
- Students individually brainstorm computing innovations they might analyze
- Consider innovations related to:
- Personal interests
- Current events
- Emerging technologies
- Familiar applications
- Societal challenges
- Students select 2-3 potential innovations to research
Main Activities (30 minutes)
-
Research on Chosen Computing Innovation (15 minutes)
- Students select their final innovation choice
- Students begin researching their innovation:
- What is the innovation and how does it work?
- When and how was it developed?
- What was its intended purpose?
- How is it actually being used?
- What data does it collect or process?
- Who are the key stakeholders?
- Students document their findings with proper citations
- Teacher circulates to provide guidance and feedback
- Students identify additional research questions to explore
-
Analysis of Impacts from Multiple Perspectives (15 minutes)
- Students analyze the impacts of their chosen innovation:
- Beneficial effects (intended and unintended)
- Harmful effects (intended and unintended)
- Economic impacts
- Social impacts
- Cultural impacts
- Legal and ethical considerations
- Privacy implications
- Accessibility and digital divide considerations
- Students consider different stakeholder perspectives:
- Creators/developers
- Users/consumers
- Businesses
- Government/regulators
- Marginalized groups
- Society at large
- Students document evidence for their impact claims
- Students identify areas needing additional research
- Students analyze the impacts of their chosen innovation:
Closing (10 minutes)
-
Development of Presentation Materials (7 minutes)
- Students begin organizing their research and analysis into presentation format
- Students determine key points to highlight
- Students plan visual elements to include
- Students outline their presentation structure:
- Introduction to the innovation
- Background and development
- Intended purpose and actual use
- Impact analysis (beneficial and harmful)
- Different perspectives
- Conclusions and implications
- Students identify any gaps in their research to address
-
Exit Ticket and Preview (3 minutes)
- Students submit their project outline and research notes
- Students identify what they plan to complete before next class
- Preview that next class will focus on finalizing and presenting projects
Assessment
- Formative: Quality of research and analysis during class work
- Project Outline: Comprehensiveness of research plan and initial findings
Differentiation
For Advanced Students
- Encourage analysis of more complex or emerging innovations
- Suggest incorporating more technical details about how the innovation works
- Challenge them to consider more nuanced or indirect impacts
For Struggling Students
- Suggest more familiar innovations with clearer impacts
- Provide more structured research and analysis templates
- Offer additional guidance on finding credible sources
Homework/Extension
- Complete additional research on chosen innovation
- Finalize presentation materials
- Prepare speaking notes for presentation
Teacher Notes
- Ensure students select appropriately scoped innovations for analysis
- Encourage students to consider both obvious and less obvious impacts
- Remind students to maintain a balanced perspective rather than advocating
- Help students find credible sources beyond marketing materials
- Emphasize that thorough analysis is more important than flashy presentations